A Piece of Cooperstown History: The Main Street B&B

If the walls of 202 Main Street could talk, they would likely tell stories of decades of hospitality and the smell of “famously indulgent” breakfasts. This stunning Victorian, built in 1893, has hit the market for $529,000, offering a rare opportunity to own a piece of Cooperstown’s living history.

For over 40 years, this property has operated as a beloved Bed & Breakfast, known for its iconic gingerbread trim and meticulously preserved period details. Stepping inside feels like a journey back to the late 19th century, featuring original natural woodwork and elegant pocket doors that anchor the double living room.

Designed for Comfort and Charm

The home is thoughtfully laid out to balance grand entertaining spaces with cozy, private nooks:

The Main Floor: Features a dining room that opens directly onto a vine-draped sitting porch—the ultimate spot for a morning coffee. It also includes a practical mudroom, extra pantry space, and a three-season enclosed room.
The Upper Levels: The second floor houses three bedrooms and three baths, plus a flexible office space. A bonus half-bath and floored storage can be found in the expansive attic.
The Carriage Barn: At the rear of the property sits a spacious two-story carriage barn. With a two-car garage and a full second story, it’s a dream for woodworkers, car enthusiasts, or those looking for studio expansion.

Location, Location, Location

Situated in the heart of the village, the home is a short stroll from Cooperstown’s crown jewels: the National Baseball Hall of Fame, the shimmering waters of Otsego Lake, and the Fenimore Art Museum. Whether you envision it as a private residence or a continued venture in hospitality, this Victorian is ready for its next chapter.

🏠 Property at a Glance

💰 Price: $529,000
📍 Address: 202 Main St, Cooperstown, NY 13326
📅 Year Built: 1893
🛏️ Bedrooms: 4
🚿 Bathrooms: 5
📐 Square Footage: 2,232 sqft
🌳 Lot Size: 9,583 sqft
🚗 Parking: 2-story Carriage Barn with 2-car garage
✨ Features: Original woodwork, pocket doors, 3-season room, and attic studio potential